aboutsummaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
path: root/testing-strategy.org
Commit message (Collapse)AuthorAgeFilesLines
* feat: consolidate zfssnapshot and zfsrollback into one subcommand-driven scriptCraig Jennings2026-04-271-0/+1
| | | | | | | | | | | | Problem: zfssnapshot and zfsrollback were two separate scripts with overlapping pre-flight checks (zfs / fzf / root) and parallel UX patterns (description sanitization in one, fzf selection in the other). Users had to remember which script was for which operation, and a "list" view meant typing the raw `zfs list -t snapshot` command. There was no path to destroy individual snapshots short of `zfs destroy` directly, which is dangerous without a confirmation flow. Solution: rewrite zfssnapshot as a single multi-subcommand script (list, create, rollback, delete). Drop installer/zfsrollback. The new script uses a source-guard at the bottom (`if [[ "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}" == "${0}" ]]; then main "$@"; fi`) so bats can source it without triggering the install-time pre-flight checks, matching the pattern in installer/archangel. Pure helpers (sanitize_description, validate_description, format_snapshot_name) get extracted as named functions so they're testable in isolation. The destructive flows (rollback, delete) keep the explicit "yes" confirmation prompt, the genesis-snapshot warning, and the recursive-rollback-destroys-newer-snapshots warning. Delete uses fzf --multi so the user can pick several snapshot names at once. Updated build.sh to copy only the consolidated script. Dropped the zfsrollback profiledef permission line. Updated Makefile, README, scripts/sanity-test.sh, and testing-strategy.org to reflect the single-script layout. Bats: 147 → 168 (+21). Coverage spans sanitize_description (normal / boundary / error), validate_description (alphanumerics, hyphens, underscores accepted; spaces, slashes, shell metacharacters, empty rejected), format_snapshot_name (timestamp + description composition), and main subcommand dispatch (list / create / rollback / delete / help / unknown). Lint clean. The zfs-, fzf-, and arch-chroot-shelling subcommand bodies stay VM-tested per testing-strategy.org.
* refactor: extract MNTPOINT constant for the install chroot mount pointCraig Jennings2026-04-271-1/+1
| | | | | | | | | | | | Last on the tech-debt drain. The installer hardcoded /mnt at 50+ sites: pacstrap, arch-chroot, mount/umount, fstab writes, and every host-side write into the chroot's /etc, /usr, /var, /boot, /tmp. Same magic-string smell as /mnt/efi but at much larger scale. Add MNTPOINT="/mnt" to lib/common.sh next to EFI_DIR. Replace literal /mnt/... with $MNTPOINT/... across installer/archangel, installer/lib/btrfs.sh, and installer/lib/common.sh. Replace bare /mnt (mount target, arch-chroot root, umount target, install_dropin parameter) with $MNTPOINT. EFI_DIR's own definition becomes EFI_DIR="$MNTPOINT/efi" for the natural composition. Folded in the related ticket: /mnt${chroot_efi_dir} in btrfs.sh:install_grub_all_efi becomes ${MNTPOINT}${chroot_efi_dir}. Was filed as a separate item but the ticket said it should ship with the MNTPOINT extraction, since the composition pattern is unusual and easy to miss in a global sed. Three /mnt references kept literal in comments where the comment describes the string concept rather than the mount point ("Remove /mnt prefix - config is used inside chroot where root is /", etc.). Substituting to $MNTPOINT in those comments would obscure the documentation. Bats: 146 → 147. One new test in test_common.bats pins MNTPOINT="/mnt". Lint clean (one shellcheck SC2295 warning fixed by quoting the parameter expansion: ${isp_firmware#"$MNTPOINT"}). VM verification deferred to a single full make test-install run after all three tech-debt commits land.
* refactor: verify GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX seds via prepend_grub_cmdline_linux helperCraig Jennings2026-04-271-1/+1
| | | | | | | | | | | | Audited the ~10 silent sed -i sites in the installer against the verification-after pattern that landed for sshd_config last session. Triaged each by failure mode. The two GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX seds in lib/btrfs.sh have a real silent-failure risk. If /etc/default/grub is missing or malformed and the sed pattern doesn't match, nothing happens. The kernel boots without cryptdevice=. The system can't unlock LUKS at boot. Added prepend_grub_cmdline_linux to lib/common.sh. Same shape as enable_sshd_root_login (sed, then grep, then error if the line wasn't modified). Replaced the two inline seds with helper calls. The HOOKS= seds in installer/archangel and lib/btrfs.sh (six total) don't need verification. A missing HOOKS= line makes mkinitcpio -P fail loudly downstream, so silent-replace failure can't reach a booted system. Added a one-line audit-rationale comment at each of the three locations so the next reader doesn't re-litigate the decision. The FILES= sed at lib/btrfs.sh:213 already self-heals via a sed-then-grep-then-append pattern, so no behavior change there. Filed a separate follow-up to lift that pattern into a named helper for clarity. Bats: 142 → 146. Four new tests in test_common.bats cover normal (empty cmdline, existing cmdline preserved, other lines preserved) and error (missing GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX line). Lint clean.
* refactor: consolidate installer defaults and FILESYSTEM validation into ↵Craig Jennings2026-04-271-1/+1
| | | | | | | | | | | | config.sh The installer had three sites touching FILESYSTEM: a top-level default in the monolith, a re-default block in gather_input, and a runtime validation block also in gather_input. The same scattering existed for LOCALE, KEYMAP, ENABLE_SSH, and NO_ENCRYPT. A future contributor changing one site wouldn't have known the other two existed. Move all five defaults into the lib/config.sh declarations so config.sh is the single source of truth. Add validate_filesystem() in lib/config.sh and call it from main() between check_config and gather_input, so a typo in a config file's FILESYSTEM= fails fast before any install action runs. The behavior change is stricter. An empty FILESYSTEM in a config file used to be silently defaulted to zfs, now it errors. Interactive mode is unaffected. select_filesystem still controls the value and already errored on cancellation. Bats: 140 → 142. Five tests added in test_config.bats for the defaults pinning and validate_filesystem coverage. Three removed from test_archangel.bats for behavior that moved out of gather_input. Lint clean.
* refactor: unify partition_disks across ZFS and Btrfs install pathsCraig Jennings2026-04-261-3/+3
| | | | | | | | | | | | The monolith's partition_disks() at installer/archangel was ZFS-only and silently shadowed lib/disk.sh:partition_disks(), which had been dead code since the Btrfs install path was added. install_btrfs was assembling partitioning manually via partition_disk (singular) plus a separate format_efi_partitions call. Two parallel implementations meant fixes had to land in two places and the lib version drifted with no visible warning. The unified partition_disks now lives in lib/disk.sh. It reads SELECTED_DISKS, dispatches the per-disk layout on FILESYSTEM (BF00 for ZFS, 8300 for Btrfs), populates EFI_PARTS + ROOT_PARTS, and formats each EFI partition with EFI0, EFI1, ... labels. Folded in two pre-existing divergences while consolidating. wipefs -af now runs on every disk, not just the ZFS path. The Btrfs path was missing this defense against non-GPT signatures (LVM, mdadm, ext) that sgdisk --zap-all alone won't touch. EFI labels standardized on EFI0, EFI1, ... across both paths. The lib version was producing asymmetric EFI / EFI2 labels. No consumer in the repo references the labels after format, so that change is cosmetic. ZFS_PARTS renamed to ROOT_PARTS for symmetry with get_root_partition. Deleted four orphaned helpers: format_efi, format_efi_partitions (only caller was the collapsed install_btrfs section), get_efi_partitions, get_root_partitions (test-only callers after install_btrfs simplified). Verified end to end: bats 134/134, make test-install passing 12/12 configs across both install paths.
* test: expand bats coverage across installer modulesCraig Jennings2026-04-261-5/+31
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Added unit tests for `disk.sh`, `btrfs.sh`, the archangel monolith's `gather_input` unattended branch, and filled gap cases in `config.sh`. The suite grew from 71 to 110 tests. `installer/lib/disk.sh` was completely uncovered. New `tests/unit/test_disk.bats` covers the four pure partition-path helpers (`get_efi_partition`, `get_root_partition`, `get_efi_partitions`, `get_root_partitions`) across SATA, virtio, and NVMe inputs, mixed arrays, and the empty-input behavior. Side-effecting functions in the same file (sgdisk, mkfs.fat, partprobe, and fzf wrappers) stay deliberately VM-tested. `installer/lib/btrfs.sh` had no bats coverage. New `tests/unit/test_btrfs.bats` covers `get_luks_devices`, the only pure helper in the file. It pins the asymmetric naming convention where the first device gets the bare `LUKS_MAPPER_NAME` and subsequent devices append the index. The archangel monolith was un-source-able for tests because its top-level code created a /tmp log file and redirected stdout via `exec > >(tee...)`, plus called `main "$@"` unconditionally at the bottom. I extracted the logging setup into an `init_logging` function called from `main`, and wrapped the main call in a `[[ "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}" == "${0}" ]]` guard. Sourcing the script now loads function definitions silently, with no log file and no banner. Running it directly works exactly as before. Verified both paths. That refactor unlocks `tests/unit/test_archangel.bats`, which covers `gather_input` in unattended mode. Required-field validation for HOSTNAME, TIMEZONE, ROOT_PASSWORD, and DISKS. Optional-field defaulting (FILESYSTEM to zfs, LOCALE to en_US.UTF-8, KEYMAP to us, ENABLE_SSH to yes). Filesystem-specific encryption checks (ZFS_PASSPHRASE required when not NO_ENCRYPT, same for LUKS_PASSPHRASE on Btrfs). Filesystem validity. RAID_LEVEL defaulting for multi-disk installs. The interactive branch stays out of scope per the testing-strategy policy. `tests/unit/test_config.bats` got five gap tests: `check_config` when CONFIG_FILE is set, `validate_config` against a non-block-device entry (e.g. /dev/null) and a missing path, and `parse_args` accepting `--color` and `--config-file` together in either order. `testing-strategy.org` got an expanded "What bats does NOT cover" section. The doc previously named six tools (mkfs, cryptsetup, zpool create, pacstrap, arch-chroot, grub-install). The new list adds sgdisk, partprobe, blkid, mkfs.fat, mkfs.btrfs, snapper, efibootmgr, mount, umount, findmnt, mountpoint, and fzf. It also names the conditions (root needed, real /dev or /sys state) that make a function VM-only. The coverage table at the top now lists the three new test files. No behavior change in production code. The init_logging extraction preserves the existing log path and banner format byte-for-byte.
* docs: document bats unit tests + sync stale README bitsCraig Jennings2026-04-131-3/+61
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | testing-strategy.org: - Frame the two test layers (bats unit / VM integration) in Overview - Add 'Unit Tests (bats)' section: what's covered, what's deliberately not, how to run, how to install, and the extract-then-test pattern - Fix stale Makefile Targets table (bats row, test row now lint+bats) README.org: - Rename 'Testing with VMs' to 'Testing' and add the two-layer framing - Surface make test / make bats / make lint in the bulleted list - Project Structure tree: drop zfs.sh (deleted last session), add raid.sh with description, add tests/unit/ entry - Point archzfs link to GitHub Releases (archzfs.com was abandoned mid-2025; url updated in code last session) - Fix #testing-with-vms internal link to match the renamed heading
* docs: add Running Tests section to testing strategy, link from READMECraig Jennings2026-02-241-0/+33
|
* docs: add testing-strategy.org with ZFS encryption notes and test recipeCraig Jennings2026-02-241-0/+287