| Commit message (Collapse) | Author | Age | Files | Lines |
|---|
| |
|
|
| |
The re-review confirmed every disposition with no new high or medium findings: Phase 1.5 stands at Ready with caveats, phases 2-5 stay parked behind the decisions fence. The response is correspondingly small — the accepted editorial rename of the Emacs subsection (its "open issue / blocks readiness" heading outlived the body, which is now an integration contract) and the second-pass note in the dispositions section. The updated review file and its history and task-tracking edits ride along.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
The review's top finding was that one Not-ready label hid an implementable slice. Status now splits by arc: Phase 1.5 helper instances are READY WITH CAVEATS (the three-ring gate and the manual drills are binding, and the ai-term.el work is a coordinated .emacs.d handoff with an exact artifact), while phases 2-5 stay NOT READY behind a decisions-required section and a Phase 5 reverification prerequisite that demotes the model table to a recommendation.
The remaining findings hardened the slice: per-ring rollback actions including the half-propagated-sync case, the review's test inventory adopted as normative, a message contract for stale helper files, and explicit roster-unavailable behavior on unsupported platforms. All recommendations accepted except the document split, modified to a dual rubric in one document. The review file and dispositions table ride along.
|
| | |
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
The detection and identity subsections were authored under one design and patched under two others. They're now three pieces: the roster as the single detection primitive, two spawn paths (deterministic launcher, startup safety net) sharing the same three steps, and identity plus the role contract, with helper-mode.org named the single home of the helper rules.
Verified ai-term.el's launch mechanics in code: the startup instruction is embedded in the tmux new-session command string, so env injection is a prefix on that string, and the -A flag means one session per project, so the helper path needs its own session and buffer names. Added ai-term recommendations to ride the same handoff (roster-derived badges, agent-exit visibility, one source for opener strings) and reconciled the v0 session-context symlink question with the Phase 1.5 answer.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
The first draft of the Emacs open issue assumed eat/vterm and invented an ai --no-tmux mode for a tmux-less path that doesn't exist. Verified against the actual config: the terminal is ghostel (native emulator over libghostty-vt), and ai-term.el is already the Emacs AI launch surface, creating project-named aiv- tmux sessions with liveness badges and crash recovery.
Emacs-born agents are therefore tmux-parented like shell launches, so detection is uniform across surfaces. The remaining design is integration, not a new surface: ai-term.el's session-create learns the roster, export, and opener steps, the picker gains a [helper] badge, and the launchers share only the agent-roster script since ai-term owns its own session naming and window placement.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
gating
Two gaps block implementation. Sessions are also born from Emacs terminal buffers, where roster detection works (the scan matches process cwd, and eat/vterm shells are children of emacs) but the deterministic spawn path doesn't exist; the open issue weighs an elisp command against shelling out to ai with a no-tmux mode, leaning to the latter so the logic lives once.
Second, template sync makes "live everywhere" the default failure mode for startup.org changes, so the test strategy gains three-ring gating: bats with sleeper processes and a byte-identical no-op guarantee, a disposable sandbox project for the corruption, orphaned-helper, and raw-launch drills, then a dormant-by-construction pilot through project-scripts before the template-wide release. The Status section carries the readiness checklist and the implementation task is blocked on it.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
The launcher becomes the spawn mechanism: a shell script runs the roster check, assigns the id, and launches with the helper instructions in order, where a model-followed startup instruction can skip a step. The in-session roster check stays as the safety net for raw launches and still splits a live anchor into crashed versus concurrent.
Session-end ordering was unhandled: a helper outliving the primary stranded a dirty worktree, since the helper may not commit and the agent allowed to is gone. The git ban on helpers is concurrency-scoped, so it lifts when the helper finds itself alone at wrap-up and the last agent out closes the door with the full wrap-up. The mirror case pauses too: a primary wrapping with live helpers stops at the commit and asks whether to sweep the helper's in-flight work, wait, or leave closing to the helper.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
A second agent now discovers concurrency itself instead of being told: a stateless process scan (running agent processes, /proc cwd matched within the project root, own ancestry excluded) runs as the first action of every session, before any pull. Alone with no anchor is a fresh session, alone with an anchor is today's crash recovery, and not-alone skips startup and routes to helper-mode.org, the role-contract workflow. The scan also splits the previously ambiguous live-anchor signal into crashed versus concurrent primary.
Verified the signal live with four concurrent agents on this machine. The ai --helper launcher flag drops from mechanism to convenience. Known v1 limits recorded: sessions not running as local processes are invisible to the scan, and the match is process-cwd based.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
Four loss windows the scoped-edit discipline doesn't cover: a primary file-wide hygiene pass silently clobbering a helper's concurrent edit (gate on live session-context.d/ files before any such pass), a new primary misreading helper dirt as leftover mess (surface live helper files at startup), crash recovery for shared-file edits (helpers journal each edit before applying it), and MEMORY.md's anchor-less read-modify-write index (memory writes stay primary-only).
Backstop: every file-wide pass snapshots to /tmp before modifying. lint-org and wrap-org-table already conform; todo-cleanup — the pass that moves whole subtrees — does not, and Phase 1.5 brings it up to the invariant.
|
| |
|
|
| |
The v0 draft covered identity and message targeting for concurrent agents but not spawn mechanics or write-safety for the shared files the session-context split doesn't isolate. I added a section for the motivating case (a second Claude in one project doing lookups and safe task updates): ai --helper spawn with automatic AI_AGENT_ID, a tiered read/write contract where helpers make scoped single-heading org edits and file-wide passes plus all git mutation stay primary-only, light helper startup, and helper wrap-up. Phase 1.5 sequences the slice independently of the runtime-neutral phases 2-6.
|
|
|
Moved three inbox notes into docs/design/ so the task body links survive: pearl's two pattern-catalog handoffs and codex's v0 generic-agent-runtime spec. Added two corresponding TODOs under Rulesets Open Work, both [#C].
|
